The Yarn Conundrum

If you are a knitter, and perhaps maybe an obsessive passionate one, you have probably heard through the grapevine that Ysolda Teague has designed probably the most interesting shawl pattern/mystery knit along in existence.  She calls it Follow Your Arrow. (That link won’t show you anything, sorry.  It will just give more information in case you also want to join the frenzy).

Why is it so intriguing?

Ysolda’s MKAL consists of 5 clues, given out every Monday over 5 weeks.  Each clue contains 2 options, which flow seamlessly from which option you chose before, no matter which combination of options you are doing.  This means that one pattern can yield 32 completely different results! And actually, she gives a further option – make it solid color, or change colors, which means that really – there are 64 possible ways to knit this pattern.  Read it again. 64. SIXTY-FOUR, from one pattern.  Talk about getting your money’s worth.

My conundrum?

I cast one using the Unplanned Peacock Studio Kinky Socks in Wildflower, after much hemming and hawing over what yarn to use – do I want it two colored or just solid – how heavy, how drapey, blah blah  blah.  I started knitting, all the way through the first clue.  Then I made the mistake of checking the Ravelry forum to see what other people are doing.  Yeah….other people are casting on 2 or 3 or 5 shawls to see how the pattern unfolds.  I thought I could hold out, I really did.  I looked around at all of the projects I’ve got on the needles and I thought to myself – I don’t need to add another.

Then, I finished the Bosc scarf (YAY!) and set it to soak (and soak, and soak, and soak – the processing residue still lingers), and….well…. I have been trying really hard to stash bust, and I have  a lot of fingering weight…

image

So, I started pairing up the fiber to see if anything could yield a good two-tone shawl.

image

This color combination above is what got me started.  The blue is a skein that I just received from a swap, and the multicolor blue/purple/pink and sparkly skein next to it was a birthday present from a friend.  She spun it herself.  And colorway is called the “Cottingly Fairies”.

image

Then I put the handspun next to this lavender yarn I received, also from a swap, and loved the soft purple tons and this makes the blue really pop (this picture is more true to the color of the handspun than the previous one) and the blue of the other picture kind of masks the blue in the handspun.

image

But I like rainbows, a lot. And I saw the skein of limited edition Lorna’s Laces in the Bertha Palmer colorway and sandwiched between the bright yellow Madelinetosh and the ohana blue, I was stunned.  It’s so bright and cheery and perfect for these cold and dreary winter days.  But I don’t think I can handle THAT much yellow in a shawl.  I like yellow, it just doesn’t like being close to my face.

image

Then I thought about all the mini skeins I have from Miss Babs (and some one of a kinds from Lorna’s Laces) and I thought about ways to pair them up so I can have a wildly colored shawl.  But none of them seemed to call to me.

image

But I tried a series of grays – mini skeins and half used skeins, with a constant variable of the halo-ed alpaca I got in Seattle in May.

image

And the gray led me to this pair.  I like the way the multi-color center skein (one of a kind mill end, Lorna’s Laces) kind of mutes the bright yellow.  I don’t think I care much for the gray in that mix.

image

For a very girly combination, I put the Unplanned Peacock Studio next to the lavender.  It matches, but I’m not sure it’s really me.

image

I kept coming back to the handspun.  I like it with the blue.  I also like it with the purple pictured above.  I tried to blend the skeins to see if they worked as well as I imagined.  I’m not quite sold.

image

And then I did the same thing with the rainbow (Bertha Palmer, Lorna’s Laces) and the blue.  This is much more true to the bright color of the blue than the other pictures.  This combo made my eyes pop, and I think I may have found a winner.  But I’m still not positive.  I’m to the point where a lot of my fingering weight is limited edition, or handspun, or one-of-a-kind dye lots, or souvenir yarn.  And it’s really hard to justify using it for something I might not love.

What are your thoughts/suggestions?

And don’t say JUST KNIT THEM ALL! THERE ARE 32 OPTIONS TO PLAY WITH! Because that thought is going through my head about ten times a minute.

Are you doing this MKAL?  How is your project coming along?  Do you face the same dilemma?

4 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. harmonicoscillatorknits
    Jan 17, 2014 @ 13:53:49

    I know your pain. I’m making my own Follow Your Arrow and I had a difficult time choosing the yarn. I almost didn’t join the MKAL because I was in such a conundrum. In the end I’m glad I took the leap with the yarn I’m using. Now I just have to join you in resisting the urge to make all 64.

    Reply

  2. TheNovelGirl
    Jan 17, 2014 @ 14:02:09

    I love this idea of this knit along! I’m a new knitter (and thus, not participating!) and I’ve been looking at some pics on a Facebook group I’m in. It’s amazing to see how they’re all coming out!

    Reply

    • Little Green Pixie
      Jan 17, 2014 @ 14:25:25

      I’m resisting the urge to whisper over the internet come to the dark side….we have sheep….baaaaa

      It’s not scary. And this is a great way to learn new techniques. You have so many other people working on the same thing, struggling the way you might be, and can offer assistance and support when you get stuck. Just a thought. 🙂

      Reply

  3. Kristin
    Jan 17, 2014 @ 14:24:18

    I like the combo in the third photo down. I’m doing this MKAL as well, but in a solid (because that’s all I could find that I liked on the short notice I had).

    Happy knitting!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

http://livesoftheaerialists.com/

Just a Crazy Fiber Fairy

Pollyanna Rainbow Sunshine and the Needles of Doom

Fiber, craft, life, and random silliness

The Creative Pixie

eat up from crafty goodness with this creative mama

My Tangled Yarn Knitting Adventures

Ramblings from an obsessed knitter

Funky Air Bear

Traditional & Modern Knits

The Circus Diaries

Circus Thoughts From Circus People

art predator

art predator )'( seek to engage the whole soul

This Is What it is

A topnotch WordPress.com site

she shoots sheep shots

Just a Crazy Fiber Fairy

Half Crunchy Mom

No Extremes, No Judgement

by Annie Claire

Just a Crazy Fiber Fairy

No Parachute Theatre

theatre.aerial.dance

From My Insides Out

My journey to save myself

circus of humanity

A site dedicated to Circus/Performance Arts, Freaks and Geeks, Self-Acceptance, Financial Freedom, and Enjoying the Journey!

%d bloggers like this: